---
title: Compare commercial insurance brokers: Delegance, WithCoverage, Coverdash, Harper and more | by Delegance
description: How seven tech-enabled commercial brokers are paid, how they service an account and what they publish, with a source and date for every fact. Published by Delegance.
---

Published by Delegance Brokerage, a licensed commercial insurance broker and one of the brokers compared here. Delegance earns a flat, disclosed fee when you buy through it.

# Compare commercial insurance brokers

Choosing a broker of record decides who negotiates your program, how fast you get certificates and how much of your premium goes to the broker. This page sets seven tech-enabled brokers side by side on the points a CFO asks about, with each broker's own words and a link to where it says them.

## Where Delegance leads

- **How the broker is paid.** A flat, disclosed 5% fee in place of the 15 to 25% commission a traditional broker typically takes. You see the rate before you buy.
- **Total cost.** Total insurance expense typically falls 10 to 20% on a placement, with the same admitted carriers. Your result depends on your risk, your carriers and your current program.
- **AI agent and MCP access.** Orin, the Delegance AI agent, works in the portal, by email, text and phone. A public MCP server, a ChatGPT app, a Claude connector, a CLI and an SDK let your own AI tools get quotes and certificates.
- **Quotes and certificates.** Free quotes with no signup through the portal, the CLI or the MCP server; instant online quotes for eligible small business classes; multi-carrier quotes typically within 24 hours. Certificates of insurance in about 60 seconds, self-serve, from the portal, ChatGPT, Claude, Slack, email or phone.
- **Servicing.** A licensed human broker backs every account. Orin handles routine requests at any hour, and the broker steps in when judgment is needed.

[Get a free Delegance quote](https://portal.delegancebrokerage.com/onboarding/company?ref=comparecommercialbrokers.com&utm_source=comparison_site&utm_medium=web&utm_content=home_leads) Delegance publishes this site and earns a flat, disclosed fee if you buy through it.

## Side by side

Each entry for another broker is that broker's own statement or a check of its public pages, with the source and the date we read it. Delegance entries are Delegance's own statements.

| Criterion | Delegance | WithCoverage | Coverdash | Harper | Embroker | Vouch | Newfront |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| How the broker is paid | A flat, disclosed 5% fee in place of the 15 to 25% commission a traditional broker typically takes. You see the rate before you buy. (stated by Delegance) | Its terms list premiums, commissions, installment fees, service fees, cancellation fees or flat fees disclosed with its services. No fee or commission percentage found on its terms, licenses, company, solution, clients or home pages. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/legal/terms), read Nov 17, 2026) Client quotes on its clients page describe a flat-fee model. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/clients), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its compensation disclosure lists insurer commissions (typically a percentage of premium), contingent commissions, a per-policy Technology Access Fee and other items. No percentage or fee amount found. ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/compensation-disclosure), read Nov 17, 2026) | No compensation disclosure or fee page found on its site index (llms.txt) or home page. Its partner page says referral partners earn half of Harper's commission on business bound from their referral. ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/partners), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its disclosure says it receives usual and customary commissions or fees, may receive contingent commissions, and may on occasion negotiate a fee in lieu of or in addition to commissions. No percentage found. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/disclosure/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its disclosures say it earns commission from appointed carriers, may be paid on the performance of sold products, and may pass card or ACH fees through to you. No percentage found. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/legal/disclosures), read Nov 17, 2026) | No commission rate for business insurance found on its home page or terms. Its separate benefits (Total Rewards) terms say it may receive commissions paid by carriers, set per client order form. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/terms/total-rewards), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| Servicing | A licensed human broker backs every account. Orin handles routine requests at any hour, and the broker steps in when judgment is needed. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/self-service)) | A team of insurance experts, attorneys and claims specialists for your industry. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/solution), read Nov 17, 2026) | Software with advisors on request: "Software makes it fast, but real advisors make it right." ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/about), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says it advocates for you with the carrier when you file a claim. ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/insurance-insights/why-companies-trust-harper-restructured), read Nov 17, 2026) | You designate Embroker as broker or agent of record. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/terms/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Lists insurance placement, contract review, coverage reviews and claims advocacy among its services. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says it has hundreds of veteran brokers and dedicated service professionals. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| Self-service portal | One portal for quotes, binding, certificates, 64 endorsement and policy-change types, renewals and claims. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/self-service)) | A digital platform with policy, claims, certificate, exposure and renewal sections. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/solution), read Nov 17, 2026) | An online account where you buy policies and download proof of coverage. ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/faq), read Nov 17, 2026) | No self-service client portal advertised on its home page or site index (llms.txt). ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | An account dashboard with a Certificates tab. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/faq/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Buy coverage online; advisors when needs get more complex. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says service, payments and updates run through "a secure platform, available 24/7". ([source](https://www.newfront.com/), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| Certificate of insurance | Certificates of insurance in about 60 seconds, self-serve, from the portal, ChatGPT, Claude, Slack, email or phone. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/how-it-works)) | Says "Issue and track COIs faster". No certificate turnaround time stated. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/solution), read Nov 17, 2026) | Once a policy is active, you can "download your certificate of insurance instantly from your account", often the same day you buy. ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/faq), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says "certificates the same day you ask". ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Create a certificate under the Certificates tab in your dashboard. No turnaround time stated. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/faq/), read Nov 17, 2026) | No certificate turnaround time found on its home page or site index (llms.txt). ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | No certificate turnaround time found on its home page. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| Quotes and buying online | Free quotes with no signup through the portal, the CLI or the MCP server; instant online quotes for eligible small business classes; multi-carrier quotes typically within 24 hours. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/how-it-works)) | Advisor-led: its team analyzes your risk and forms a tailored plan. No instant online quote or online binding found on the pages checked. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/solution), read Nov 17, 2026) | Quote, compare, buy and download proof of coverage online. "For most policies you can be covered the same day you apply." ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/faq), read Nov 17, 2026) | Call-first: "You make one call and Harper makes the rest." Says quotes come back in minutes. ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says you can apply for most of its digitally enabled policies and packages in minutes. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/faq/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says companies can get quotes and buy coverage online, with advisors for complex needs. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Broker-led: "Technology should enhance human expertise, not replace it." No instant online quote found on its home page. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| AI agent and MCP access | Orin, the Delegance AI agent, works in the portal, by email, text and phone. A public MCP server, a ChatGPT app, a Claude connector, a CLI and an SDK let your own AI tools get quotes and certificates. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/llms.txt)) | No MCP server listed at www.withcoverage.com/.well-known/mcp.json (HTTP 404 when checked). ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/.well-known/mcp.json), read Nov 17, 2026) | Offers partner platforms an embedded insurance API: "a one-line embed, prebuilt components, or a full API build". ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/partnerships), read Nov 17, 2026) No MCP server listed at www.coverdash.com/.well-known/mcp.json (HTTP 404 when checked). ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/.well-known/mcp.json), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says it built "an agentic insurance harness" to work with carriers that have no public API. ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/engineering/ambient-agents), read Nov 17, 2026) No MCP server listed at www.harperinsure.com/.well-known/mcp.json (HTTP 404 when checked). ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/.well-known/mcp.json), read Nov 17, 2026) | Describes an "AI-powered document ingestion feature" for its brokers. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/company-news/embroker-2024-progress/), read Nov 17, 2026) No MCP server listed at www.embroker.com/.well-known/mcp.json (HTTP 404 when checked). ([source](https://www.embroker.com/.well-known/mcp.json), read Nov 17, 2026) | No MCP server listed at www.vouch.us/.well-known/mcp.json (HTTP 404 when checked). ([source](https://www.vouch.us/.well-known/mcp.json), read Nov 17, 2026) | Offers Benji, a benefits chat assistant for Slack-enabled clients. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/blog/instabase-pilots-newfront-benefit-assistant-ahead-of-oe), read Nov 17, 2026) No MCP server listed at www.newfront.com/.well-known/mcp.json (HTTP 404 when checked). ([source](https://www.newfront.com/.well-known/mcp.json), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| Licensing | Licensed in all 50 states and DC, agency NPN 21282686. Appointed directly by 25 carriers, including Chubb, Travelers and The Hartford. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/llms.txt)) | Its licenses page lists a license for each of the 50 states and DC. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/licenses), read Nov 17, 2026) | A licensed insurance producer in 51 US jurisdictions. ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its site footer lists license numbers for California and Georgia. No state count stated. ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its licenses page lists license numbers by state. No state count stated. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/licenses/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Licensed in all 50 states; NPN 19926463. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Licensed in all 50 states, DC and Puerto Rico. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/terms), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| What it is | An independent commercial insurance brokerage. Delegance places coverage with insurance companies and does not underwrite the risk itself. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/vs-traditional-broker)) | Describes itself as "the risk management solution for ambitious businesses", with an AI platform supporting its team, and invites you to replace your traditional insurance broker with it. ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/solution), read Nov 17, 2026) | Describes itself as "a digital insurance agency" for small businesses, startups, freelancers and e-commerce merchants. ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Calls itself "a commercial insurance brokerage for small and mid-sized businesses in every industry and state". ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | Acts as broker or agent of record; its FAQ calls it "an intelligent insurance platform". ([source](https://www.embroker.com/terms/), read Nov 17, 2026) | "Vouch is a broker, not an insurance carrier," placing business through Vouch Specialty Insurance Services, LLC. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | A brokerage that "has officially joined WTW", the global broker Willis Towers Watson. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/), read Nov 17, 2026) |

## Head-to-head pages

- [Delegance vs WithCoverage](/vs/withcoverage): Says it serves "ambitious businesses". ([source](https://www.withcoverage.com/solution), read Nov 17, 2026)
- [Delegance vs Coverdash](/vs/coverdash): Says it serves small businesses, startups, freelancers and e-commerce merchants. ([source](https://www.coverdash.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026)
- [Delegance vs Harper](/vs/harper): Says it serves small and mid-sized businesses in every industry and state. ([source](https://www.harperinsure.com/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026)
- [Delegance vs Embroker](/vs/embroker): Says it blends "the personalized touch of a broker with the speed and convenience of technology". ([source](https://www.embroker.com/), read Nov 17, 2026)
- [Delegance vs Vouch](/vs/vouch): Says it primarily serves young, venture-backed B2B companies building software, AI, fintech, hardware and healthtech products. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026)
- [Delegance vs Newfront](/vs/newfront): Describes itself as a San Francisco-based broker "combining deep specialty expertise and cutting-edge technology". ([source](https://www.newfront.com/about), read Nov 17, 2026)

## Common questions

### What does a broker of record change?

A broker of record letter moves servicing of an existing policy to a new broker. The policy, the carrier and the coverage stay the same until renewal. The new broker takes over certificates, changes and the next renewal.

### How do I find out what my current broker earns?

Ask in writing for the commission rate on each policy, any contingent or supplemental commissions, and any fees. Many brokers publish a compensation disclosure that lists the types of pay without the rates.

### Does a lower broker fee mean thinner coverage?

No. The fee is the broker's pay; the coverage is set by the policy the carrier issues. Compare the same limits, deductibles and carriers side by side.

### Who publishes this comparison?

Delegance Brokerage publishes it and is one of the brokers compared. Every statement about another broker links to that broker's page and shows the date we read it.

Read the [guide](/how-to-choose) or the [sources and method](/sources).

[Get a free Delegance quote](https://portal.delegancebrokerage.com/onboarding/company?ref=comparecommercialbrokers.com&utm_source=comparison_site&utm_medium=web&utm_content=home_end) Delegance publishes this site and earns a flat, disclosed fee if you buy through it.

---

Published by Delegance Brokerage, a licensed commercial insurance broker and one of the brokers compared here. Delegance earns a flat, disclosed fee when you buy through it. This site is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any other company named on it. Company names belong to their owners and appear in plain text only.

Every statement about another broker links to that broker's own page and shows the date we read it. See [sources and method](/sources). To correct a fact, write to [alex@delegancebrokerage.com](mailto:alex@delegancebrokerage.com).

Insurance is placed by Delegance LLC dba Delegance Brokerage, NPN 21282686, 234 10th Ave, New York, NY 10011. Nothing here is an offer of insurance; coverage is subject to underwriting and policy terms. Savings figures are typical results, not a promise.
